2004 Picks
- All-American Snack
- Amuse-Bouche
- Anti-Vegetarian Feast
- Antipasti
- Asian Fusion
- Astoria Alternative
- Bitched-About Restaurant
- Brunch With Parents
- Culinary Arts Education
- Elegant Restaurant
- Fowl
- Group of Ten
- Hamburger Alternative
- Hot Date
- Ice Cream
- Impress a Foodie
- Inventive Dish
- Last Meal on Earth
- Lobster
2003 Picks
- Avant-Garde Sushi
- Baked Potato
- Barbecued Brisket
- Bargain Prix Fixe
- Brooklyn Bistro
- Calzone
- Cheap Eat
- Chocolate Treats
- Classic Burger
- Waiters
- Classic Cocktails
- Dim Sum
- Fast Food
- Fried Chicken
- Gelato
- Ice-Cream Sundaes
- Indian
- Italian
- Italian Cooking Class
- Kid-Friendly
- Lasagne
- Lighting
- Lunch to Impress
- Mac 'n' Cheese
- Meatballs
- Meatloaf
- Meze
- Middle Eastern